Showing posts with label literary films. Show all posts
Showing posts with label literary films. Show all posts

Friday, August 5, 2016

Literary Movie Churches: Moby Dick (1956)

 How come when people talk about Moby Dick, they only talk about the whale? They talk about whether the whale represents God or Evil or Truth. (In the film, one of the sailors says, "If God ever wanted to be a fish, he'd be a whale.") Or they talk about Captain Ahab, the one-legged madman, and how his obsession represents all of our obsessions, and whether it was Khan in Star Trek 2 or Picard in Star Trek 8 who made a pompous point of quoting him. Or they talk about whether Moby Dick works best as an adventure story or as a philosophical treatise.


But they hardly ever talk about the church in Moby Dick. And it's sort of an awesome church, both as it was described by Herman Melville in the novel and as it's portrayed in John Huston's 1956 film.


Before the narrator of the book (and film), Ishmael, goes off to sea, he goes to church. The novel was published in 1851, and the story takes place somewhere around that time. The story begins in the whaling community of New Bedford, Massachusetts, the city from which Melville himself set off as a whaler.


In the film we see what looks like most of the town’s population flowing into a beautiful white chapel. Ishmael says that "few are the fishermen bound for the Indian Ocean or Pacific who fail to visit there." The walls of the church are covered with stone tablets and plaques that serve as memorials to sailors who died at sea (example: "In Memory of Captain Seth Culn, who was taken out of his boat by a foul line on the off shore ground in the Pacific -- March 3rd, 1828. This tablet is erected to his memory by his mother.")


We hear the congregation singing heartily, and everyone seems to have a hymnal, which speaks well of the church's finances. There is an even mix of men and women, young and old. Sailors are well represented.


As the congregation sings, the pastor emerges through a door in the front of the sanctuary. Father Mapple (played by the immense Orson Welles) sports the impressive beard of an Old Testament prophet and wears the garb of a sea captain.


The pulpit is built to look like the bow of a ship, with a large cross jutting out upwardly. Mapple climbs rigging (a rope ladder) to get into the pulpit. This probably wouldn't be allowed with the 1986 Americans with Disabilities Act, but it's cool.


Mapple preaches on the Book of Jonah, and one wonders if he ever preaches on anything else. (Well, I'm sure he touches more than occasionally on the "I will make you fishers of men" passage. And he does refer to the Apostle Paul as the Great Pilot.) His sermon begins with a quote from the book, "God fashioned a fish." Throughout the film and throughout the novel, whales are called fish, not mammals. There is a very funny chapter in the novel that explains that whales are fish, because the Bible in Jonah says a fish ate the prophet (though maybe it was a shark).


Mapple addresses his congregation as "shipmates." "Shipmates," he says, "The sin of Jonah was his disobedience of the command of God; it was a hard command. All the things God would have us do are hard. If we are to obey God, we must disobey ourselves." Now I have some issues with that. Most of Psalm 119 is about how delight found in the laws of God. For example, Psalm 119: 14, reads, "I enjoy living by your rules."  


Still, it is true that at times God asks difficult things, and it's good that Father Mapple doesn't back off from that. Everyone seems to appreciate his preaching because, after all, who can enunciate like Orson Welles?


The reason I really like this church, though, is the theme aspect of the church. I think other churches should go with this idea. Someone should build a church next to the Indianapolis Motor Speedway that looks like a track. The pulpit could be built like a racecar, and the preacher could address the congregation as his "pit crew." Or a church next to a ballpark could have the pitcher could preach from the mound with a text from Genesis 1, you know, "In the big inning..."  The possibilities are endless. But for now, I'll just give 3 steeples to Moby Dick's New Bedford church.

Monday, August 1, 2016

Massachusetts literary films on the small screen

Massachusetts is one of the states with many films either set or made in the state. There are more than I can cover this week, and I needed some way to limit things. This is a state with many of the nation’s great literary names, so we’ll go with film adaptations of literary works. (Sadly, this will leave out many great Mass. films, such as The Way, Way Back, a favorite of mine.) The limitation also provides an introduction to our MovieChurches Friday post theme this month: Literary Churches.

When I was in high school, my drama teacher wanted to stage the Arthur Miller (fictionalized ) retelling of the Salem witch trials, The Crucible. My drama teacher believed the drama made telling points about a current political issue. He didn’t have enough guys available for parts, so the production never happened. I had been unsure about doing the play, partly because the church comes out horribly in the play. But then again, the Salem church didn’t handle things so well in history.

The 1996 version of The Crucible tells the story very well. Daniel Day Lewis does his usual magnificent work as John Proctor, a man falsely accused of witchcraft, and Winona Ryder is very good as an accuser. But the most interesting casting is Paul Scofield as Judge Thomas Danforth, the very antithesis of his role as Thomas More in A Man for All Seasons. The film is set, of course, in Salem, Massachusetts. It was filmed in various parts of the state.

Though the Church doesn’t come off so well in the film, individual Christians are portrayed as admirable people, faithful to God and their consciences, willing to pay the ultimate cost.

The coast of Massachusetts is the setting for other literary stories as well. Some will argue that Moby Dick is not only the greatest American novel, it is simply the greatest novel ever written. (Not me. I’m on your side Crime and Punishment.) Friday’s MovieChurches post is about John Huston’s 1956 version of the story. The story begins in the state and locations for the film include New Bedford and Nantucket.

You might not be surprised to read that Henry James’ novel, The Bostonians, is primarily set in Massachusetts or that James Ivory’s 1984 adaptation of the tale of 19th Century feminism was filmed chiefly in the state. The film also provides a chance to see Christopher Reeve without a cape or glasses and Nancy Marchand before she was a Soprano.

The Wayside in Concord, MA (Home to Hawthorne and Alcott)
Massachusetts native Nathaniel Hawthorne set his classic novel, The Scarlet Letter, in colonial Boston. It continues to be read in high school English classes. (Or the Cliff Notes version of the novel is still read by high school English classes. At least the underlined sections of the Cliff Notes of The Scarlet Letter that belonged to older siblings continues to be read.) The story of a woman persecuted for bearing a child out of wedlock has had a number of big and small screen adaptations. The 1926 silent version with LIllian Gish remains relatively true to the story in spite of being filmed in California. The 1995 version starring Demi Moore as Hester Prynne was filmed in Canada, and the storyline is even more distant from the original.

The beloved novel, Little Women, set in Concord, Massachusetts, has also been made into a movie many times. The author, Louisa May Alcott, was another Massachusetts native (in fact, Alcott and Hawthorne lived in the same Concord house at different times). The 1933 version of the story, starring Katharine Hepburn and directed by George Cukor, was all filmed in California. The 1949 version with Elizabeth Taylor and directed by Mervyn Leroy was also a California studio product. The 1994 version with Winona Ryder and directed by Gillian Armstrong wasn’t made in California but Canada.

Apparently, there have have been films in Massachusetts in periods of time after the Civil War. Daniel Keyes turned his award winning 1959 short story “Flowers for Algernon” into the award winning novel Flowers for Algernon, which was adapted into the 1968 film Charly, which won Cliff Robertson the Best Actor Oscar. The science fiction film about a man with a low I.Q. turned into a genius is wonderful, but heartbreaking. The film is set and was filmed in Massachusetts.

Dennis Lehane is a living Massachusetts native who is a bestselling and award winning author. Many of his novels and short stories have been made into films. His novel Mystic River, about three friends who struggle with a history of sexual abuse, was adapted into a 2003 drama by director Clint Eastwood. It won Sean Penn an Oscar for Best Actor and Tim Robbins an Oscar for Best Supporting Actor. Lehane’s best selling novel Gone Baby Gone was adapted and directed in 2007 by Ben Affleck (who didn’t act in the film). Ben got a great performance out of his brother, Casey, in this film about kidnapping. (Children suffer much in Lehane’s world.) In 2010, Martin Scorsese directed a film of Lehane’s very odd novel about an insane asylum, Shutter Island. (All three of these films are set and were filmed in Massachusetts.)

All of the films above were adapted from works by truly great writers. Some film theorists say that better films can often be made from second rate works of literature. Maybe that’s why the trashy beach read by Peter Benchley, Jaws, is probably the best film ever made in and about the state.